The project that I started as an assignment for this workshop is about my grandmother’s grandmother who was left abandonded in 1841. Where does she come from? How was her life like? Who was she? And subsequently, where do I come from?
Research in the archives gave answers to the facts but how to put this into photography I didn’t know. I started to make photos by associating but also went to places where she’s been living. In the workshop I hoped to be given direction in this project, about how my photography can be used to tell this story.
I got the assignment to write down all the facts about the life of my ancestors including my mother’s, my own and my daughter’s.
Besides that, Michael Ackerman advised me to read W.G. Sebald, who’s integrated (old) photographs in his novels, resulting in a combination of facts and fiction. The use of text in a project like this is inevitable and may be the best starting point. The facts of the story can give the freedom to accumulate images which can lead to a multi-layered story. To make it more personal I can inlcude my daughter in the project, for example.
But what to present in the final portfolio then? My older series ‘wonder’ consists of 53 images, of locations where humans are key, but are hardly ever present. My problem with this work is that they are all single images put together, which is convincing in style and feeling of the images, but there is no bigger story or project with a beginning and an end. For me, that was the reason to attend the workshop. How to make use of my way of photographing things in a predefined project? The answer I got this week is that this isn’t always necessary. The single images can always be made parallel to certain projects and can even be integrated in a project. For the portfolio I combined some images of the ‘wonder’ series with newer material and with images I made in Paris during the workshop. Together they make a new chapter.
Portfolio from the Photographie Introspective workshop with Michael Ackerman, November 2013.
Written review by
ANDREAS J. HIRSCH,
Independent curator, writer and photographer
As Noortje Schmit explains in her text, she found an answer to a question about a specific project she brought into the workshop. The set of 12 photographs she put together as a result can be seen as standing by itself as well as in possible relation to her project about an ancestor. The outcome was, if we follow her report from the workshop, that text would come first and existing images might be added later. So the concentration on finding a photographic expression of the family story was replaced by a more relaxed way of contextualising photographs. This may be an unsual precondition for putting together a porfolio like this one, but surely it is a valid one for working with photographs and imagery in a more general sense.
We see photographs almost devoid of people, only in two occasions there seem to be people visible in reflections. Some photographs show life animals, others artificial ones. Most of the nature visible is artificial as well, as in a zoo or in a museum. One photograph indicates a circus or similar form of entertainment. Only one photograph contains text, the line "HERE IS ALWAYS THERE", and it show a structure which seems to be part of a railway station. Again no people to be seen. – And Noortje insited that her photographs were actually about people.
In fact, people are responsible for almost everything that can be seen on those photographs. It is a man-made world that Noortje is showing us. We may suspect that it is owed to the patience of the photographer that there are (almost) no people visible, but also a different scenario could have taken place: That the pictures show a world without people, a recurring theme in an apocalyptic sub-genre of science-fiction literature. It was a genre which was especially famous when the knowledge about the global destruction potential of nuclear warfare hit the public mind in the 1950ies and 1960ies. The space suit in image 4 seems to support this version, while the animals strangely do not disturb it. Animals have also returned to Chernobyl, which is still toxic land.
Noortje's ancestor she is working about, was - as she tells us - left abandoned. The premises on the photographs have this abandoned touch and the life animals also might have been abandoned. Several of the photographs in the series show doors or windows, through which someone might well have recently left the scene. Notably in image number 5, where the curtain elements do not hang down evenly, the still lingering presence of someone only just gone, is maybe strongest.
In the first and in the last image there is a barrier blocking the way. In image 1 the barrier blocks the way for us and probably also for the animal that seems to have turned away and changed direction, thus moving out of the frame. In image 12 the barrier keeps the horse from going away, keeps it confined, which would mean it was condemned to death if it was actually abandoned.
The horse is also the only living being in the series that comes real close to the camera, almost getting in touch with it. – I notice that when looking at the photographs so far, I am never referring to the photographer, which I would usually be inclined to do. Maybe the feeling of abandonment is so strong that we feel alone in and with the scenes and that the photography seems anonymous. Which, I would be inclined to say, is a compliment to the photographer.
Noortje mentions that W.G. Sebald was recommended to her by Michael Ackerman. Sebald's very special blend of fact and fiction, of ficticous fact and factual fiction, is probably a very good recommendation for a situation where the historic facts about one's ancestor are slim. Without knowing the texts she has written, we can see from the photographs she selected how she is actually pursuing this path.
The prevailing feeling of abandonment in a double sense in those photographs and the dream-like, failing efforts of orienting ourselves – all this perfectly relates to the partially intuited and imagined ancestor. It is an interesting way to go that also seems to be consistent with Noortje's other photographic work. The missing link of fact and fiction, of knowledge and imagination, of text and photographs has been found.
La disparition ...
by Thomas Glaser (France)
Charlotte S. 24...
by Sophie Libermann (France)
So close, so fa...
by Thierry Laporte (France)
by Martin de Haan (The Netherlands)
Here and Now
by Dagmara Bojenko (France)
by Lucie Poinsatte (France)
by Jean Paul Abjean (France)
by Jessica Bordeau (France)
[:en]Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.[:fr]Les cookies nécessaires sont absolument indispensables au bon fonctionnement du site. Cette catégorie comprend uniquement les cookies qui assurent les fonctionnalités de base et les fonctionnalités de sécurité du site Web. Ces cookies ne stockent aucune information personnelle.[:es]Las cookies necesarias son absolutamente esenciales para que el sitio web funcione correctamente. Esta categoría solo incluye cookies que garantizan funcionalidades básicas y características de seguridad del sitio web. Estas cookies no almacenan ninguna información personal.[:]
[:en]Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.[:fr]Tous les cookies qui peuvent ne pas être particulièrement nécessaires au fonctionnement du site Web et qui sont utilisés spécifiquement pour collecter des données personnelles des utilisateurs via des analyses, des publicités et d\'autres contenus intégrés sont appelés cookies non nécessaires. Il est obligatoire d\'obtenir le consentement de l\'utilisateur avant d\'exécuter ces cookies sur votre site Web.[:en]Las cookies que pueden no ser particularmente necesarias para el funcionamiento del sitio web y que se utilizan específicamente para recopilar datos personales del usuario a través de análisis, anuncios y otros contenidos integrados se denominan cookies no necesarias. Es obligatorio obtener el consentimiento del usuario antes de ejecutar estas cookies en su sitio web.[:]