Fanny Lelievre 33 ans DA / Graphiste Photographe amateur. C’est une recherche d’écriture photographique personnelle et l’envie d’expérimenter le lien qui existe entre le sujet et le photographe, dans d’autres conditions que celles de la photo de rue que je connais davantage, qui m’amène à ce workshop avec Richard Dumas.
C’est une expérience très personnelle qui va s’ouvrir à moi. Je pensais axer mon travail sur la capture des émotions venues des modèles, et je me rends compte que, lorsque je cherche du vrai, du sensible, du « naturel », le modèle renvoie ce que je lui donne ou ce que je lui permets ou propose de me donner.
C’est ainsi que naît la série « Laisser-aller … ». N’étant ni habituée, ni intéressée par la mise en scène de mes situations de prises de vue, j’ai souvent demandé à mes modèles de ne rien faire de particulier, et à contrario, eux, ayant l’habitude d’être dirigés, se sont trouvés en situation, d’incompréhension, d’ennui, de réflexion, et ont fini par me donner un peu d’eux-même en miroir… Après une suite d’émotions énoncées ou mises en exergue lors des lectures intermédiaires de mes editing (nostalgie, colère, tristesse…) je me rends compte que mes photos proposent à voir ce que je suis là et maintenant : en difficulté d’abord, puis en doute, puis sur la voie de quelque chose… Mon écriture personnelle est toujours en développement et ma quête des émotions est en éveil pour la suite de mon travail dans le domaine de l’Art Thérapie. Et me laisser aller, encore…
Portfolio from the Portrait workshop with Richard Dumas, October 2014.
Written review by
ANDREAS J. HIRSCH,
Independent curator, writer and photographer
In her set of 12 photographs, Fanny Lelièvre displays different approaches she takes on portrait photography. While the 12 photographs do not form a series, they may be structured along certain distinctions between them. One that immediately becomes appearant is the glance of the eyes of the people portrayed. Almost all of them glance aside, some even seem to turn away from the camera.
Only in images 5 and 9 do they look at us. When we see them looking at us, their emotions become more easily readable. This may be considered an advantage when grasping a person through a portrait photograph, but it at the same time makes the expression easier to read which includes any forced or "acted" emotions. In this set the portraits where we do not meet the eye of the portrayed turn out stronger and more subtle in the play of emotions.
There exists a tendency among curators and editors, who look at portfolios, to demand consistent series of images or projects to be presented to them, not individual images. This tendency may be questionable, but it does not come without reason, when considering exhibitions and publications they key ways of getting attention for your photographs. Also does the series or project add more layers of narration and meaning to the set of images, which a simple best-of-collection could offer.
If we apply this approach to the images submitted by Fanny Lelièvre here, we might select the first three photographs, numbered 1 to 3. Not because they are the first in this set, but because they seem to me the strongest ones in the entire set and they show the potential to work as individual photographs as well as when seen in context, as a triplet that is in this case.
In all three photographs the person is not looking at us. There clearly is quite strong emotion there, although it remains somewhat enigmatic, which I would consider as a key quality. In terms of composition and the work with light and shadow they offer different approaches, which all work nicely. The compositions are strong and clear, they help create a certain tension. The way the light is used – on the face only, or the arm in the foreground or on the background – supports the forming of a mood in the picture.
There is relatively little to be seen in the background. We learn very little about the context of the person portrayed, but just enough to make us curious. We can guess the structure of a wall, see what might be a sany beach of some entirely different kind of landscape or perceive traces of nature, a bush maybe in the background. Giving the viewer just enough to spark the imagination – this is done very well here. It carries the abovementioned enigmatic quality further until it almost borders on the narrative. We start imagining stories behind the photographs and this is the best thing that can happen.
Singling out those three photographs does not mean that the other images do not share some of the qualities mentioned here, but those three pictures combine all of them and so turn out the strongest ones in the set. From those three we could build further, imagine a series that strives to go along those lines and to refine those qualities ever more. Working on such a series, which I would clearly recommend, does not mean to force this "series"-thinking on the photographer for all her future work, but to serve as an exercise in order to sharpen the sense of the qualities perceived.
Consequentially try to pick out only the strongest images for a project or portfolio, only those who really work – and discard anything that might be just good enough, even if you feel personally attached to it for some reason. As they say in this often quoted rule for editing texts: "Kill your darlings!"
Take time to select your models, find out which person might be right for your kind of photography. And stay with reduction, regarding the carefully chosen settings as well as clothing, etc. Ask yourself, where does the emotion sit in the images? It will not be in a single spot, but in a combination of many factors, some of which I tried to address before. Capturing the emotion is also about "seeing" it with one's eyes closed, practically as well as metaphorically speaking.
This is also about sensing the person in front of your camera, given her or him the feeling of being at ease with you, ultimately being themselves. Let go of "created" emotions and standard poses, since they will show and you simply do not need them.
Working in your own, very personal mode may take some time and patience, but is clearly something that you are able to achive, as we see wonderfully from those three photographs.
More Portfolios
This is how it ...
by Sophie Glasser (France)
A MOMENTARY LAP...
by Bruno Mazodier (France)
A Woman through...
by Lydia Zhou (USA)
Beautiful Count...
by Ocie Bridwell (USA)
A day without a...
by Wouter Tuil (The Netherlands)
The beginning o...
by Danielle O’Daly (USA)
Abandonment/Lef...
by Patricia La Prairie (USA)
Patine
by Jacque Rupp (USA)
We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.
This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
[:en]Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.[:fr]Les cookies nécessaires sont absolument indispensables au bon fonctionnement du site. Cette catégorie comprend uniquement les cookies qui assurent les fonctionnalités de base et les fonctionnalités de sécurité du site Web. Ces cookies ne stockent aucune information personnelle.[:es]Las cookies necesarias son absolutamente esenciales para que el sitio web funcione correctamente. Esta categoría solo incluye cookies que garantizan funcionalidades básicas y características de seguridad del sitio web. Estas cookies no almacenan ninguna información personal.[:]
[:en]Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.[:fr]Tous les cookies qui peuvent ne pas être particulièrement nécessaires au fonctionnement du site Web et qui sont utilisés spécifiquement pour collecter des données personnelles des utilisateurs via des analyses, des publicités et d\'autres contenus intégrés sont appelés cookies non nécessaires. Il est obligatoire d\'obtenir le consentement de l\'utilisateur avant d\'exécuter ces cookies sur votre site Web.[:en]Las cookies que pueden no ser particularmente necesarias para el funcionamiento del sitio web y que se utilizan específicamente para recopilar datos personales del usuario a través de análisis, anuncios y otros contenidos integrados se denominan cookies no necesarias. Es obligatorio obtener el consentimiento del usuario antes de ejecutar estas cookies en su sitio web.[:]